Conscription As An Omen---Who Said It?

[Shooterman]

This needs to be replicated in it's entirety. A link will be given later in the thread, hopefully after debate.

There is one step now proposed, supported by government propaganda, which seems to me to strike at the very basis of freedom. It is the proposal that we establish compulsory military training in time of peace. The power to take a boy from his home and subject him to complete government discipline is the most serious limitation on freedom that can be imagined. Many who have accepted the idea favor a similar government-controlled training for all girls.

There is no doubt that the government, and particularly the War and Navy departments, are straining every nerve to secure the enactment of this legislation. Secret meetings are being held in the Pentagon Building and elsewhere. Recently the chief executive officers of some forty or more women's organizations were invited there, and it is said they were addressed by the Secretary of Defense, the Secretary of the Navy, the Under Secretary of State, General ______, Admiral ____, and other high-ranking officers. The ladies were requested not to disclose the substance of the speeches made or identify the Defense Department or its officials with the sponsorship of the plan …

Government propaganda is bad enough when it is open, but it is inexcusable when secret. We may expect a flood of open propaganda after the ground has been prepared, and everyone who is opposed to the plan will be pictured as for war and for unpreparedness.

We have fought this war to preserve our institutions, not to change them. We have fought it to permit us to work out our problems here at home on a peaceful foundation, not on a foundation dominated by military preparations for another war. The question of the best form of military organization should not be an emotional problem. It should be dealt with by argument and not by propaganda. But the methods being used threaten the freedom of this country, for if they are successful they can be used to fasten upon us every kind of regulation, price control for business, wage control for labor, production control for farmers….

Military conscription is essentially totalitarian. It has been established for the most part in totalitarian countries and their dictators led by Napoleon and Bismarck. It has heretofore been established by aggressor countries. It is said it would ensure peace by emphasizing the tremendous military potential of this country. Surely we have emphasized that enough in this war. No one can doubt it.

On the contrary, if we establish conscription every other nation in the world will feel obliged to do the same. It would set up militarism on a high pedestal throughout the world as the goal of all the world. Militarism has always led to war and not peace.

Conscription was no insurance of victory in France, in Germany, or in Italy. The countries with military conscription found that it was only an incident and not the determining factor in defense or in victory.

Military training by conscription means the complete regimentation of the individual at his most formative period for a period of twelve months. If we admit that in peacetime we can deprive a man of all liberty and voice and freedom of action, if we can take him from his family and his home, then we can do the same with labor, we can order the farmer to produce and we can take over any business. If we can draft men, it is difficult to find an argument against drafting capital.

Those who enthusiastically orate of returning to free enterprise and at the same time advocate peacetime conscription are blind to the implications of this policy. They are utterly inconsistent in their position. Because of its psychological effect on every citizen, because it is the most extreme form of compulsion, military conscription will be more the test of our whole philosophy than any other policy.

Some say it is unconstitutional. It makes very little difference whether it actually violates the terms of the Constitution. It is against the fundamental policy of America and the American Nation. If adopted, it will color our whole future. We shall have fought to abolish totalitarianism in the world, only to set it up in the United States.

Note, I have taken some liberty to hide the time frame in which this was said.

Anyone care to guess as to whom may have said this?

[sfga6970]

Woodrow Wilson after WWI?

[Shooterman]

Originally Posted by sfga6970

Woodrow Wilson after WWI?

Nope, that SOB got far too many American boys killed in WWI to worry about a small thing like a draft.

[filthybeast]

Is this the Truman speech what was it O heck 47, 48 0r 49?

[sfga6970]

Then possibly FDR in the run-up to WWII.

[Shooterman]

Originally Posted by filthybeast

Is this the Truman speech what was it O heck 47, 48 0r 49?

No, Truman was a conscriptionist.

[Shooterman]

Originally Posted by sfga6970

Then possibly FDR in the run-up to WWII.

No, that Bustard had to have the conscription laws in place to fight the war.