Go Back   Trackpads Community > General Discussions > Point/Counterpoint

Point/Counterpoint Debate newsworthy and other 'hot-button' topics here. If it can be debated, this is the forum for it. Can't be thin skinned - people will disagree with you. No flaming or personal attacks.

Point/Counterpoint

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 02-06-2007, 09:06   #8 (permalink)
NCO
 
milmor_1's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Bronze Vehicle ID Medal Bronze Reviews Medal Silver Factsheets Medal Silver Commanders Coin Bronze Factsheets Medal Bronze Community Medal Silver Threads Medal 
Total Awards: 7
My Mood
Status
milmor_1 is offline
Post Count
2,131
My Photos
My Photos: 197
Staff Title
Moderator Commander, S&S Club Leader
Member Flags
Ireland
My Referrals
My Referrals: 0
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
milmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud ofmilmor_1 has much to be proud of
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 36,435.24
Bank: 0.00
Total T-Bucks: 36,435.24
 

 
Default Re: Blue on Blue Tape classified By USA

Heres more on this subject,

Beckett asks U.S. for Iraq friendly fire death Tuesday February 6, 12:31 PM

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Foreign Secretary said on Tuesday London was working with the United States to get as much information on a "friendly fire" incident in which U.S. warplanes in Iraq killed a British soldier in Iraq.

"Obviously, both we and the U.S. are keen to understand what has happened here," Margaret Beckett said during a visit to Jerusalem, after the media showed clips of a classified cockpit video recording from one

(Advertisement)
of the U.S. warplanes involved.
Lance Corporal Matty Hull was killed near the southern Iraqi city of Basra in March 2003 when two U.S. A-10 tankbusters twice fired on the British convoy.

An inquest into Hull's death was adjourned last week after the coroner said he had no choice but to delay his verdict until the recording of the incident was produced by the Ministry of Defence. The MoD said it did not have the right to release the video without the permission of the U.S. government.

"We want as complete an inquest as possible," Beckett said. "We want the coroner to have access to as much evidence as possible. We are working with the U.S. to achieve that."

Beckett added that the relationship between Britain and Washington -- often criticised at home because of Prime Minister Tony Blair's support for the war in Iraq -- remained strong.

"The matter is important and needs to be resolved but we are confident it will be kept in proportion," she said.

The recording showed how before firing on a British convoy the U.S. pilots concluded that the orange panels on top of their armoured vehicles -- designed to show allied planes a convoy was friendly -- must be rocket launchers.

Realising afterwards that they had hit the convoy one pilot said: "We're in jail, dude."

Beckett asks U.S. for Iraq friendly fire death - Yahoo! News UK
milmor_1 is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-06-2007, 13:50   #9 (permalink)
Monkey Mouse
 
Woodmonkey's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Gold Staff Service Medal Gold Reputation Medal Bronze Referrals Medal Bronze Magazine Medal Silver Gallery Medal Gold Donations Award 2 Blue Star Silver Donations Award 
Total Awards: 12
My Mood
My Mood:
Status
Woodmonkey is offline
Post Count
57,146
My Photos
My Photos: 109
Staff Title
Trackpads XO
Member Flags
United States us connecticut
My Referrals
My Referrals: 15
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
Woodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond repute
Petz
Other Swag
Blog Entries: 1
T-Bucks: 82,744.88
Bank: 2,073,251.87
Total T-Bucks: 2,155,996.75
     
     
     
   

 
Default Re: Blue on Blue Tape classified By USA

I hope this issue is resolved and soon. I know that, if it were an American killed by friendly fire from a Brit, we would want full cooperation in the investigation.
__________________
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
How May I Help You?





PM me through this link if clicking on those banners doesn't help with your questions

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Woodmonkey is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-06-2007, 15:06   #10 (permalink)
Jr. Officer
 
leobold1's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Silver Staff Service Medal Silver Reputation  Medal Silver Commanders Coin Marine Corps Service Button Army Service Button Bronze Community Medal 1 Blue Star Silver Threads Medal 
Total Awards: 8
My Mood
My Mood:
Status
leobold1 is offline
Post Count
5,002
My Photos
My Photos: 17
Staff Title
Moderator Commander
Member Flags
United States us texas
My Referrals
My Referrals: 0
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
leobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud ofleobold1 has much to be proud of
Social Networking View Member's YouTube Profile
Other Swag
Blog Entries: 2
T-Bucks: 10,074.75
Bank: 222,616.77
Total T-Bucks: 232,691.52
     

 
Default Re: Blue on Blue Tape classified By USA

The Sun Online - News: Joy at direct hit turns to horror

By TOM NEWTON DUNN
Defence Editor
February 06, 2007

THE Sun today publishes the full, disturbing truth about how the US pilot of an A-10 tankbuster jet broke all the rules to shoot up a British convoy in the Iraq war.

We obtained the cockpit videotape at the centre of a diplomatic row between the two Allies.

It shows how the pilots — reservists who had never been in action before — made SIX crucial errors.

They left 25-year-old Lance Corporal of Horse Matty Hull dead and four comrades from the Household Cavalry Regiment seriously injured.

Click here to see the shocking video

On the tape, one pilot — call sign POPOV36 - appears to gloat sickeningly during the attack.

He is egged on by the second — call sign POPOV35 — who encourages: “Get him, get him!”

Looking down at the chaos as a soldier drags burning comrades from the vehicles, he adds: “It looks like he is hauling ass. Ha Ha.”

A second burst of fire is unleashed 98 seconds after the first. Moments later the pilots are told the truth over the radio.

As they take in the horror, POPOV35 says: “We’re in jail dude”. POPOV36 weeps as they return to base: “God dammit. F*** me dead.”

The “top secret” tape has been seen by the Oxfordshire coroner who is holding L/Cpl Hull’s inquest, but both the Ministry of Defence and the US government have REFUSED to let him show it in court.

L/Cpl Hull’s widow Susan, of Wiltshire, was even told it did not exist.

She said last night: “I’m very relieved this is being made public at long last. I can’t believe these pilots can discuss what they’re doing so casually when these are the last moments of my husband’s life.”

Defence officials insist their hands were tied by a legal pledge with the Pentagon not to reveal any of their secrets. But we can reveal there is NOTHING secret on the tape. But it WILL cause appalling embarrassment.

The tragedy unfolded on March 28, 2003 — day seven of the invasion to topple Saddam. The two single-seat, slow-flying jets were nearing the end of a two-hour mission to destroy artillery and rocket launchers from Saddam’s 6 Armor Division, dug in 25 miles north of Basra.

They were being guided to their targets by Forward Air Controllers from the US Marine Corps — embedded with British ground units and relying on maps, intelligence and the pilots’ own vision.

At the same time, the convoy of British armoured vehicles — two Scimitars and two Spartans — were moving north to probe enemy lines.

They were inside an area US pilots had been told not to shoot into, and carried orange overhead canvas panels used to identify coalition forces to aircraft. They also displayed thermal reflectors and Union Flags.

Circling at an altitude of 12,000ft, the A-10s spotted Iraqi vehicles 800 yards north, and the British patrol less than three miles west. ERROR ONE came when they asked the Forward Air Controller, call sign Manila Hotel, if friendly forces were around the Iraqi vehicles — not to the west. In ERROR TWO neither pilot gave the precise grid references for the Household Cavalry patrol to double check its identity.

ERROR THREE saw them convince themselves the identification panels were really orange rocket launchers.

In ERROR FOUR POPOV36 decides to attack, saying he is “rolling in” — without permission from the Forward Air Controller. POPOV35 asks for artillery to fire a marker round into the target area to clear up confusion.

But ERROR FIVE came when POPOV36 attacked without waiting for it. In ERROR SIX POPOV36 strafes the column for a second time but still doubts its identity.

Only the bravery of Trooper Chris Finney, 18, stopped further attacks. He jumped on a burning vehicle to radio in a Mayday report and call off the strike, dragged a badly wounded comrade from the inferno, then went back in for L/Cpl Hull. He was injured and won the George Cross.

POPOV36 is known to be a lieutenant colonel, and POPOV35 a major, but their identities have never been released. Neither has the result of a US Air Force inquiry.

Last night a senior US military source told The Sun: “This tape needs to get out. The pilots need to be brought to account.”

An MoD spokesman said: “There has never been any intention to deliberately deceive or mislead L/Cpl Hull’s family. We did inform them some classified material had been withheld.”

We have now handed the video tape recording taken from the cockpit of the A10 ground attack jet to the Oxfordshire Coroner’s office.

Assistant Deputy Coroner Andrew Walker, who is hearing the inquest into Lance Corporal of Horse Matty Hull’s death, has expressed his gratitude.

t.newtondunn@the-sun.co.uk

----------------------

Bold and Italics are from original article.
__________________
Compel others: Do not be compelled by them
Sun-Tzu

leobold1 is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-06-2007, 15:14   #11 (permalink)
Monkey Mouse
 
Woodmonkey's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Gold Staff Service Medal Gold Reputation Medal Bronze Referrals Medal Bronze Magazine Medal Silver Gallery Medal Gold Donations Award 2 Blue Star Silver Donations Award 
Total Awards: 12
My Mood
My Mood:
Status
Woodmonkey is offline
Post Count
57,146
My Photos
My Photos: 109
Staff Title
Trackpads XO
Member Flags
United States us connecticut
My Referrals
My Referrals: 15
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
Woodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond repute
Petz
Other Swag
Blog Entries: 1
T-Bucks: 82,744.88
Bank: 2,073,251.87
Total T-Bucks: 2,155,996.75
     
     
     
   

 
Default Re: Blue on Blue Tape classified By USA

Quote:
POPOV36 is known to be a lieutenant colonel, and POPOV35 a major
So neither was a novice pilot.
__________________
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
How May I Help You?





PM me through this link if clicking on those banners doesn't help with your questions

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Woodmonkey is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-07-2007, 14:12   #12 (permalink)
Non-Commissioned Officer
 
jonathan_ddr's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Trackpads Sharpshooters 
Total Awards: 1
My Mood
Status
jonathan_ddr is offline
Post Count
347
My Photos
My Photos: 10
Member Flags
United Kingdom
My Referrals
My Referrals: 0
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
jonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nicejonathan_ddr is just really nice
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 646.00
Bank: 0.00
Total T-Bucks: 646.00

 
Default Re: Blue on Blue Tape classified By USA

THanks Leabold1 for the link to the tape.
I agree they made lots of mistakes, including chatting over the controllers radio broadcast and getting mixed up.

How they think without looking that the orange squares were rockets,... I don't know!? ; as all vehicles had these.

Jon
__________________
"Is it just me but am I the only sane person on this planet "

www.forces80.com

I may not be around often but I am watching you!

I LOve Woodmonkey

I wish it to be known that I do not condone the actions of the EU or the UN

I also wish it to be know that I am of BRITISH descent and in fact not a member of the EU and should not be addressed as a EUROPEAN.

RULE BRITANNIA

Last edited by jonathan_ddr; 02-07-2007 at 14:25..
jonathan_ddr is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-07-2007, 14:23   #13 (permalink)
Monkey Mouse
 
Woodmonkey's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Gold Staff Service Medal Gold Reputation Medal Bronze Referrals Medal Bronze Magazine Medal Silver Gallery Medal Gold Donations Award 2 Blue Star Silver Donations Award 
Total Awards: 12
My Mood
My Mood:
Status
Woodmonkey is offline
Post Count
57,146
My Photos
My Photos: 109
Staff Title
Trackpads XO
Member Flags
United States us connecticut
My Referrals
My Referrals: 15
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
Woodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond repute
Petz
Other Swag
Blog Entries: 1
T-Bucks: 82,744.88
Bank: 2,073,251.87
Total T-Bucks: 2,155,996.75
     
     
     
   

 
Default Re: Blue on Blue Tape classified By USA

Quote:
I LOve Woodmonkey
__________________
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
How May I Help You?





PM me through this link if clicking on those banners doesn't help with your questions

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Woodmonkey is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-07-2007, 14:39   #14 (permalink)
Dazed and Confused