Go Back   Trackpads Community > General Discussions > Point/Counterpoint

Point/Counterpoint Debate newsworthy and other 'hot-button' topics here. If it can be debated, this is the forum for it. Can't be thin skinned - people will disagree with you. No flaming or personal attacks.

Point/Counterpoint

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 10-08-2005, 15:06   #1 (permalink)
Monkey Mouse
 
Woodmonkey's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Gold Staff Service Medal Gold Reputation Medal Bronze Referrals Medal Bronze Magazine Medal Silver Gallery Medal Gold Donations Award 2 Blue Star Silver Donations Award 
Total Awards: 12
My Mood
My Mood:
Status
Woodmonkey is online now
Post Count
57,809
My Photos
My Photos: 108
Staff Title
Trackpads XO
Member Flags
United States us connecticut
My Referrals
My Referrals: 15
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
Woodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond repute
Petz
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 67,366.33
Bank: 1,238,977.44
Total T-Bucks: 1,306,343.77
     
     
     

 
Default A White Oppressor? Who Me?

Quote:
Quote:
A White Oppressor? Who Me?
Quote:
Your daughter is enrolled at a major university that has well-defined policies prohibiting discrimination on the basis of race. She decides to attend a campus event. The organizers forbid her entry because of her skin color: white.

Under concerted pressure from the Student Government Association, which prohibits racial discrimination at school-sponsored events, the organizers grudgingly admit your daughter. But they make a point of publicly humiliating her from the podium for the color of her skin.

On Sept. 25, the Women's Studies and Graduate Consortium at Northeastern University in Boston held a public on-campus meeting called "Breaking Bread: Women of Color Dialogue." White women were barred.

The SGA demanded that no student be denied entry to a public, on-campus event because of skin color. This was not merely a moral stand but also a demand that the university-sponsored event comply with the university's non-discrimination policy. (Exclusion on the basis of gender seems to have raised no comment.)

Rather than cancel the event, Dr. Robin Chandler — director of women's studies and an organizer of the event — cracked the door wide enough for white women to walk through. Only one attended — a senator from the SGA. Her presence was obviously meant to make the point that students cannot be excluded from campus events due to race.

In NU, Northeastern's student newspaper, Chandler described her response to allowing a white woman to attend.

"I welcomed her anyway, in addition to telling the audience to conduct themselves with integrity even though the presence of a white woman was unwelcome," she said.

Chandler continued, "I think it's a shame that one or two white students based on white privilege, a lack of awareness of racial issues and a lack of generosity of spirit complained to the office of the provost and were able, because they were white, to gain admission to the morning session that I was forced to open up."

At a university-funded event some while back, Chandler gave a closing speech that was followed by speeches from spectators, who were encouraged to come on-stage to "share their thoughts about diversity and oppression."

I'd like to take Professor Chandler up on the offer to share my thoughts.

First of all, in what dictionary did Chandler look up the word "welcome?" And since when has protesting discrimination demonstrated a "lack of awareness of racial issues" and a "lack of generosity of spirit?"

Before deteriorating into an uncharacteristic rant, however, I should clarify where I stand on the "race question." For most of my life, I have been neither proud nor ashamed of being white — although I rather enjoy being Irish. My race is not something I achieved; it is a circumstance of birth over which I had no control. I judge people, including myself, on the content of their character and their actions.

My family through marriage includes blacks, Hispanics, and plain vanilla sorts like me. Race is simply not an issue.

Nevertheless, I've heard the charge of "white privilege" so often that I've numbed to its meaning and implications. That is a mistake. The accusation is too often a racial attack, and those who hurl it are too often oppressors in sheep's clothing.

Chandler's remarks broke through my numbness. Why? My three nieces are university age or close to it. One is black; two are blonde and fair-skinned. Chandler would have broken up a family along racial lines rather than let them attend a public event together. And she would have labeled anyone who protested as a "racist," a recipient of white privilege.

"White privilege": the phrase has different meanings depending on the context, but most often the accusation rests on historical analysis.

Namely, due to the great historical wrong of slavery — a wrong that no one denies — whites are said to have sins to expiate.

For most white people, however, history frowns upon this interpretation. Again, I use my family as an example.

In 1865, when slavery ended in America, my ancestors were on ships fleeing the famine and political oppression in Ireland. A third of the passengers died in transit; many more perished from privation in a foreign land.

The family on my husband's side fled Cuba as Castro made his power grab. Their children literally had to maneuver through explosions on the streets of Havana in order to attend school.

These are not people of privilege. They have no connection to or responsibility for the oppression that was slavery.

There are no laws that grant my blonde-haired nieces any privilege due to skin color. Such laws have been methodically removed from the legal system for decades now.

Nevertheless, attendees said they would feel "threatened … if white women were present." White women, they claimed, could not understand issues like prostitution and truancy. As a white woman who has lived on the street, I disagree.

The preceding sentence contains the worst impact of Chandler's racial policies: "as a white woman." While writing this column, I've thought of myself as a racial category and I've wanted to vigorously defend being white. It is difficult to be part of the only race for whom racial pride is a social taboo.

This is the ultimate result of people who want to open or close a public door based solely on skin color. They force you to think in racial categories, and that process can become a slippery slope into racism. It is a slide I refuse to make.
Click here for the source
of this article
__________________
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
How May I Help You?





PM me through this link if clicking on those banners doesn't help with your questions

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Woodmonkey is online now  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Trackpads Information
Click to Visit
Old 10-08-2005, 15:45   #2 (permalink)
Fallen Member
 
USA11B's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Navy Service Button Army Service Button Bronze Community Medal Bronze Threads Medal 
Total Awards: 4
My Mood
Status
USA11B is offline
Post Count
1,790
My Photos
My Photos: 0
Member Flags
United States Undisclosed
My Referrals
My Referrals: 0
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
USA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to allUSA11B is a name known to all
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 2,632.00
Bank: 0.00
Total T-Bucks: 2,632.00

 
Default Re: A White Oppressor? Who Me?

What whips those College Administrators must be!
I am at a loss as to how this could occur on October 04, 2005.
Had the reverse situation been, whites barring anyone, you can rest assured it would make the headlines as the Aruba debacle.
Dr. Robin Chandler — director of women's studies and an organizer of the event — should attend a few classes on equality herself.
USA11B is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 10-08-2005, 16:00   #3 (permalink)
Razak's Roughneck
 
JohnRN's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Silver Reputation  Medal Bronze Community Medal 
Total Awards: 2
My Mood
Status
JohnRN is offline
Post Count
6,442
My Photos
My Photos: 60
Staff Title
EDIV Trivia Coordinator
Member Flags
India us new jersey
My Referrals
My Referrals: 0
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
JohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to beholdJohnRN is a splendid one to behold
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 7,084.17
Bank: 0.00
Total T-Bucks: 7,084.17

 
Default Re: A White Oppressor? Who Me?

This is really dumb.

Not to mention pretty darn offensive too.

If I'm trying to defeat racism and discrimination, wouldn't I be making a stronger case by having AS MANY people from DIFFERENT RACES participating? Wouldn't it send a message "Look! Look, it doesn't matter who you are or where you come from! We are all the same here!"

How on Earth do you defeat discrimination by mariginalizing yourself by practicing discrimination on your own? Have people forgotten MLK Jrs. speech? How about all the white folk who supported the Civil Rights Movement?

People like these make me sick. I echo USA11B's snetiment - I cannot believe that this is happening in the United States of America, October of 2005.
__________________
No time for losers, you make the call
Believe in yourself, stand tall
Another day, it's in your hand
You can be the winner, in the end

The weak will fall the strong remain
No pain no gain
JohnRN is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 10-10-2005, 22:26   #4 (permalink)
Racy Ol' Lady
 
Snowden's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Silver Staff Service Medal Silver Reputation  Medal Silver Commanders Coin Silver Commanders Coin Silver Donations Award Gold Community Medal Gold Threads Medal 
Total Awards: 7
My Mood
My Mood:
Status
Snowden is online now
Post Count
47,953
My Photos
My Photos: 37
Member Flags
United States us maryland
My Referrals
My Referrals: 6
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
Snowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant futureSnowden has a brilliant future
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 428,403.85
Bank: 0.00
Total T-Bucks: 428,403.85
     
     

 
Default Re: A White Oppressor? Who Me?

It would be interesting, wouldn't it, to have Martin Luther King, Jr. witness this. He was a man with a cause - racial equality. The other day, I received an email of hate aimed at him - that same old canard about his name being "Michael" something-or-other; saying he was a complete fraud. (This, despite the "Jr." at the end of his name.) I imagine most of us have had that missile pass before our eyes. Oh - yes. This came from a person who declares a total lack of anyl prejudice, although the prejudice is obvious.

I suggest that he was a gentleman; a man who wanted peaceful acceptance as a member of the human race - one race, one people, and all equal.

This woman, Dr. Robin Chandler, very likely spews forth great admiration for him, and calls on his name as an example. She does this from a deep pit of ignorance about him and all he stood for.
__________________
Life's a banquet and most poor suckers are starving to death!


MOTM, Jan 2005, Aug 2007
Golden Cookie Award, 2005.
Aug 2006 Perv of the Month
Perv. Outreach Award, 2007
Snowden is online now  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 10-10-2005, 22:38   #5 (permalink)
 
The_Federalist's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Gold Staff Service Medal Army Service Button Bronze Community Medal 
Total Awards: 3
My Mood
Status
The_Federalist is offline
Post Count
1,038
My Photos
My Photos: 63
Staff Title
Moderator
Member Flags
United States us nevada
My Referrals
My Referrals: 0
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
The_Federalist has disabled reputation
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 1,508.76
Bank: 0.00
Total T-Bucks: 1,508.76

 
Default Re: A White Oppressor? Who Me?

Quote:
Northeastern University in Boston
That alone puts this in context.
__________________
"Artillery Lends Dignity to What Would Otherwise be a Vulgar Brawl"
The_Federalist is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 10-10-2005, 23:44   #6 (permalink)
Monkey Mouse
 
Woodmonkey's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Gold Staff Service Medal Gold Reputation Medal Bronze Referrals Medal Bronze Magazine Medal Silver Gallery Medal Gold Donations Award 2 Blue Star Silver Donations Award 
Total Awards: 12
My Mood
My Mood:
Status
Woodmonkey is online now
Post Count
57,809
My Photos
My Photos: 108
Staff Title
Trackpads XO
Member Flags
United States us connecticut
My Referrals
My Referrals: 15
Personal Guestbook
Reputation +/-
Woodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond reputeWoodmonkey has a reputation beyond repute
Petz
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 67,366.33
Bank: 1,238,977.44
Total T-Bucks: 1,306,343.77
     
     
     

 
Default Re: A White Oppressor? Who Me?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Snowden
It would be interesting, wouldn't it, to have Martin Luther King, Jr. witness this. He was a man with a cause - racial equality. The other day, I received an email of hate aimed at him - that same old canard about his name being "Michael" something-or-other; saying he was a complete fraud. (This, despite the "Jr." at the end of his name.) I imagine most of us have had that missile pass before our eyes. Oh - yes. This came from a person who declares a total lack of anyl prejudice, although the prejudice is obvious.
I bet that I know who that totally unprejudiced person is.

Typical of her to try and tear Martin Luther King, Jr down. Was he perfect? No. Is anyone perfect?
__________________
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
How May I Help You?





PM me through this link if clicking on those banners doesn't help with your questions

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Woodmonkey is online now  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 10-11-2005, 09:34   #7 (permalink)
 
AT3Weins's Avatar
My Awards Rack
Gold Staff Service Medal Bronze Reputation  Medal Gold Gallery Medal Trackpads Experts Navy Service Button Silver Community Medal Silver Threads Medal 
Total Awards: 7
My Mood
Status
AT3Weins is offline
Post Count
4,724
My Photos
My Photos: 8,118
Staff Title
MDIV Commander
Member Flags
United States us california
Reputation +/-
AT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of lightAT3Weins is a glorious beacon of light
Other Swag
T-Bucks: 21,696.26
Bank: 0.00
Total T-Bucks: 21,696.26
  

 
Default Re: A White Oppressor? Who Me?

You guys should see and hear some of the crap I do on a daily basis here.


Quote:
Originally Posted by google search
Definitions of white privilege on the Web:
  • White privilege, or Privilege du blanc, is a privilege held by Catholic queens and the Grand Duchess of Luxembourg wherein they are allowed to wear white when in an audience with the Pope. Protocol for papal audiences requires long-sleeved, formal black garments and a black veil for women.
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_privilege_(royalty)

  • White privilege, or White Skin Privilege, is used as a term of analysis -- employed by, among others, historians, legal scholars, philosophers, opponents of the Eugenics Movement and sociologists of racism -- to denote a particular kind of alleged social relation, one which typically involves a right, advantage, exemption or immunity granted to or enjoyed by white persons beyond the common advantage of nonwhites. ...
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_privilege_(sociology)
__________________
Non sibi sed patriae

Photos Video Downloads Factsheets Quizzes Announcements

AT3Weins is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.us