Point/CounterpointDebate newsworthy and other 'hot-button' topics here. If it can be debated, this is the forum for it. Can't be thin skinned - people will disagree with you. No flaming or personal attacks.
Iraq veteran seeking conscientious objector status
The Associated Press
Updated: 8:57 p.m. ET Jan. 20, 2005
SAVANNAH, Ga. - The Army has brought charges against a soldier who refused to return to Iraq for a second combat tour because he now objects to war, officials said Thursday.
advertisement
[Blocked Ads]Sgt. Kevin Benderman notified his commanders Dec. 28 that he was seeking a discharge as a conscientious objector. He then refused orders to deploy with his unit Jan. 8 while the Army processed his objector claim.
Benderman was charged with desertion and a second count that accuses him of intentionally skipping his deployment flight.
“My response to those charges is not guilty,” said Benderman, 40. “I am prepared to deal with whatever consequences my action brings.”
Benderman, an Army mechanic with 10 years in the military, spent eight months in Iraq in 2003 with the 4th Infantry Division from Fort Hood, Texas. He transferred to Fort Stewart after returning from the war.
getCSS("3088867");FREE VIDEO
• Returning to war
Jan. 20: The soldiers of the 3rd Infantry Division are heading back to Iraq after being on the front lines of a tumultuous march to Baghdad that left 46 soldiers dead. NBC's Mike Taibbi reports.
Nightl News
Though he never fired a gun in combat, Benderman says the misery he saw firsthand — including a badly burned young girl and mass graves filled with men, women and children — led him to seek objector status.
Fort Stewart commanders contend Benderman still had an obligation to deploy with his unit while they considered his conscientious objector application.
“The people that it hurts the most are those people who are a close-knit part of his team,” Maj. Gen. William G. Webster, the 3rd Infantry commander, told reporters Thursday. “But if you talk to these soldiers here, it’s sort of below the noise level.”
Army investigators must now decide whether to prosecute Benderman in a court-martial or allow his case to be handled administratively, said Lt. Col. Robert Whetstone, a Fort Stewart spokesman.
If convicted by a court-martial, Benderman faces up to seven years in a military prison, reduction in rank and a dishonorable discharge, Whetstone said. Military courts can also opt for no punishment, even for defendants found guilty.
Benderman has since been assigned to a rear-detachment unit with no restrictions. He said he has even been granted two weeks of leave that he will use to prepare his case.
“We’re still going to treat him with honor and respect. He’s a soldier, he’s wearing the uniform and he’s a veteran,” Whetstone said. “But when regulations are broken and orders are disobeyed, we’ve got to do what we’ve got to do.”
These kinda guys make me wany to hurl. Yes, he did go once before, but as a soldier, we realize that duty must overide personnal freedoms from time to time. If he was a true objector, he would have declared it the first go around.
My question to him would be why join the Army if you don't want the responsibilities associated with being a soldier?
__________________
"Bustin my ass to save yours"- OIF 03-04
You know I never really understand why the media finds this to be some big news story. I mean the first few they reported on may have been but really I do not see the news worthiness of the story. Of course that is just me and I have from time to time looked a bit too far into things.
You know I never really understand why the media finds this to be some big news story. I mean the first few they reported on may have been but really I do not see the news worthiness of the story. Of course that is just me and I have from time to time looked a bit too far into things.
No! When was that?
The thing is that these kind of stories all have a different little twist to them once the media gets ahold of it. And with all the hype of us being over there and the media slamming us for it, they are going to look for this kind of trash...
Point/Counterpoint
01-21-2005, 18:14
Army charges soldier for refusing Iraq stint 
FREE VIDEO
